Finding the Hidden Problem Behind Everyday Behavior
Why the best Original Oratories ask why we do the things we do.

Have you ever typed out an entire text message, reread it seventeen times, decided it sounded weird, deleted it, and then spent the next twenty minutes wondering why nobody ever talks to you? Or said "I'm fine" while being so visibly upset that even your dog looked concerned? Maybe you've pretended not to see someone you know at the grocery store because you didn't feel like having a conversation, so instead, you spent six minutes intensely examining a shelf of canned beans.
Human beings are strange. We make decisions that contradict our own interests, follow social rules nobody remembers creating, and repeat behaviors that make our lives unnecessarily difficult. And most of the time, we don't even notice. That's what makes everyday human behavior such valuable material for Original Oratory.
Some of the strongest speeches begin by questioning something everyone does but almost nobody thinks about.
The challenge is figuring out what that behavior actually reveals.
1. The Behavior Isn't Always the Problem
One of the most common mistakes students make when developing an OO is assuming that the behavior they've noticed is automatically the problem they should address. Let's say you've noticed that people avoid difficult conversations. You might immediately decide to write a speech about conflict avoidance, which is a reasonable starting point. But what exactly are you criticizing? Are people afraid of confrontation? Do they lack communication skills? Have they been taught that disagreement is disrespectful? Are they protecting relationships they don't want to lose? Those explanations might sound similar, but they lead to very different speeches.
Consider two possible arguments. The first is that people avoid difficult conversations because they don't know how to communicate effectively. The second is that we've confused keeping the peace with preserving relationships, teaching ourselves that discomfort is more dangerous than dishonesty.
The first focuses on a lack of skills, while the second challenges a belief about what healthy relationships require. Neither is automatically correct, and both would need evidence, but the second opens a more interesting question: What happens when people believe that being agreeable is the same as being kind?
They might suppress legitimate concerns, avoid setting boundaries, or allow resentment to accumulate because they don't want to appear confrontational. Suddenly, the speech isn't simply about having difficult conversations. It's about how our understanding of kindness might be preventing us from practicing it.
The behavior is your starting point. The belief behind it is often where the real argument begins.
2. Ask "Why?" Until the Easy Answers Stop Working
When students identify a problem, their first explanation is often the most obvious one. People judge others because they're judgmental. People avoid conflict because they're uncomfortable. People don't ask for help because they're independent. Technically, those sentences contain words. Unfortunately, they don't explain much. A useful exercise is to keep asking why until you uncover something that actually explains the behavior.
Let's use asking for help. You notice that people refuse assistance even when they're struggling. Why? Perhaps they don't want to appear weak. But why would asking for help make someone appear weak? Because they've learned to associate independence with competence and strength. And why is that association potentially harmful? Because needing support becomes evidence of personal inadequacy rather than a normal part of being human. Now we're getting somewhere. We've moved from an observable behavior to a potentially deeper belief about identity and self-worth, and that belief gives us something worth investigating.
However, there's an important warning here. Asking "why" helps generate explanations. It doesn't prove they're true.
A student who refuses help might fear appearing incompetent. Another might have experienced unreliable support. Someone else might be protecting their privacy or genuinely prefer working alone. Your job isn't to decide which explanation sounds the most dramatic. Your job is to determine which explanation the evidence supports. That's the difference between discovering an argument and inventing one.
3. Look for the Social Rules Nobody Agreed To
Every society operates according to expectations that aren't necessarily written down. We know we're supposed to say "bless you" when someone sneezes. We know that when someone asks, "How are you?" the socially acceptable response is usually "Good," even if your entire life is currently being held together by caffeine and an increasingly concerning playlist. We know we're supposed to appear confident during interviews, humble after accomplishments, and enthusiastic when someone shows us forty-seven vacation photos. Nobody sat us down and explained all these rules. We just learned them. Some are harmless, while others deserve closer examination.
For example, consider the expectation that successful people should always be productive. A student finishes their homework, practices their speech, studies for an exam, and finally sits down to relax. Within ten minutes, they feel guilty. Why? Perhaps they've internalized the belief that time only has value when it produces something measurable. Now the behavior of feeling guilty while resting becomes evidence of a broader cultural assumption about productivity and personal worth. That assumption might influence how people treat leisure, relationships, physical health, or even their identities. But before declaring productivity culture responsible for every exhausted teenager in America, investigate whether research supports that connection.
The strongest OOs often examine the invisible rules we've mistaken for common sense.
4. Find the Contradiction Between What We Value and What We Practice
Contradictions are especially useful because they expose the distance between our ideals and our behavior. We celebrate individuality but punish people for being different. We encourage honesty but become defensive when someone tells us an uncomfortable truth. We value friendship but hesitate to reach out without a specific reason. We praise resilience but sometimes shame people for needing support. We tell students that failure is essential to learning while treating mistakes as evidence of incompetence. Each contradiction contains the beginnings of an argument.
Let's examine friendship. Most people would agree that friendships matter. We celebrate birthdays, post appreciation messages, and tell people to cherish their relationships. Yet imagine wanting to contact an old friend. You open their messages, type "Hey, how have you been?" and stop. You haven't spoken in months. What if they think it's strange? What if they assume you want something? What if you're bothering them? So you delete the message. You want connection, but you've convinced yourself that connection requires justification.
That contradiction could lead to a speech about transactional relationships: the tendency to evaluate interactions according to what they provide or accomplish. Notice that we're not simply accusing people of being selfish. We're examining how a seemingly reasonable expectation might interfere with something we genuinely value. That's a much stronger foundation for an OO.
When developing your argument, look for the moments when our behavior undermines our own values.
5. Use Psychology to Explain, Not to Diagnose
Once students identify a behavioral pattern, they often turn to psychology. That's a good instinct. Psychological research can help explain why people seek certainty, resist vulnerability, conform to social expectations, or avoid uncomfortable experiences. But psychological terminology should clarify your argument, not decorate it.
Suppose you're writing about people jumping to conclusions. You discover the concept of the need for cognitive closure, which researchers use to describe a preference for definite answers over ambiguity. That concept could help explain why some people reach conclusions prematurely when faced with uncertainty. But it doesn't mean every person who misreads a text message has a psychological disorder, and it certainly doesn't mean you should announce, "According to psychology, everyone is terrified of uncertainty." Psychology rarely works that neatly. People behave differently depending on their personalities, experiences, environments, and circumstances.
Instead, ask whether the research directly explains the behavior you're discussing, whether it supports the specific claim you're making, and whether you're accurately representing its findings. Research about social anxiety isn't automatically evidence for a speech about conflict avoidance, and a study showing an association between two behaviors doesn't necessarily establish that one causes the other. Don't turn a cautious academic finding into a universal declaration just because it sounds more impressive. Credible research should make your argument more precise, not more exaggerated. Remember, the goal isn't to impress judges with how many psychological terms you can pronounce. It's to help the audience understand themselves.
6. Follow the Behavior into the Real World
An interesting psychological explanation is only the beginning. To build a meaningful OO, you need to establish why the behavior matters.
Let's return to conflict avoidance. Imagine a student who doesn't tell a friend that a joke hurt their feelings. That's a small, recognizable moment. Now consider how the same pattern might appear in other settings. An employee might hesitate to report a workplace problem, a family member might avoid discussing a growing resentment, or a community might discourage criticism because disagreement threatens its image of unity.
These examples illustrate how the same underlying belief could appear in different situations, but they aren't proof that one cause explains every case. This is where research becomes essential. You need evidence connecting the behavior to meaningful consequences. A useful way to think about this is moving from the micro to the macro.
Start with the individual and ask what this behavior costs one person. Then expand outward and consider what happens when the same pattern is reinforced by families, schools, workplaces, institutions, or communities.
A strong speech connects the two without pretending that every societal problem can be traced to a single psychological tendency. The small example helps your audience recognize the behavior, while the larger consequence helps them understand its significance. Together, they make the argument feel both personal and important.
7. Don't Confuse a Relatable Observation with a Universal Truth
Here's where many promising OO topics go wrong. A student notices something in their own life and assumes everyone experiences it. "I feel guilty when I rest, so society must be obsessed with productivity." "My friends avoid confrontation, so our generation must be incapable of difficult conversations." "Someone ignored my text, so modern relationships are collapsing." Perhaps, but personal experiences are starting points, not population-level evidence.
Before building an entire speech around an observation, ask whether it appears beyond your immediate circle. Look for research, expert analysis, reporting, and real-world examples that establish the behavior's relevance, and be willing to discover that your original explanation was incomplete. For instance, someone who avoids conflict may not be afraid of discomfort. They may have learned through experience that confrontation can be unsafe. Someone who refuses help may not be obsessed with independence. They may lack access to trustworthy support.
These distinctions matter because a nuanced OO doesn't pretend everyone behaves the same way for the same reason. It identifies a meaningful pattern, explains the conditions under which it occurs, and demonstrates why that pattern deserves attention.
Your job isn't to prove that everyone is guilty. It's to prove that the problem is real.
8. The 3P Hidden Problem Exercise
This exercise is designed to help you move from an everyday observation to a researchable argument.
Step 1: Become an observer of human behavior. For one week, pay attention to the little things people do without thinking. Notice awkward interactions, contradictory decisions, unspoken expectations, and habits that seem unnecessarily complicated. Stand-up comedy is particularly useful here because comedians make careers out of noticing how absurd ordinary behavior can be. They'll spend five minutes explaining why everyone pretends to understand the rules of tipping, why people say goodbye six times before leaving a conversation, or why we suddenly forget how to walk when someone holds a door open from fifty feet away. The joke reveals the behavior. Your job is to investigate what the behavior reveals about us.
Step 2: Write down 10 everyday observations. Don't worry about whether they're important yet. Maybe you've noticed that people apologize before asking for help, assume silence means disapproval, feel guilty for doing nothing, pretend to agree to avoid awkwardness, or struggle to admit they don't understand something. Other possibilities include comparing our progress to other people's achievements, treating changing our minds as a weakness, or feeling compelled to explain why we're saying no. At this stage, you're simply collecting observations rather than deciding which ones deserve an entire speech.
Step 3: Ask why each behavior might exist. Write down at least three possible explanations for each observation. For example, if you notice that people struggle to say no, perhaps they fear disappointing others, associate agreeableness with kindness, or worry that setting boundaries will damage their relationships. Don't choose your favorite explanation yet. The purpose is to recognize that one behavior can have several possible causes.
Step 4: Identify the hidden belief. For each possible explanation, ask what assumption might make the behavior seem reasonable. Someone who struggles to say no might believe, "If I disappoint someone, they'll think less of me," or "Being a good person means being available whenever someone needs me." These assumptions are possible foundations for an argument because they reveal the beliefs that may be influencing our decisions.
Step 5: Look for the contradiction. What do people claim to value, and how might their behavior undermine that value? For example, we encourage people to establish healthy boundaries, yet sometimes treat those who enforce them as selfish. That contradiction creates tension and gives you something worth investigating beyond the obvious observation that people have difficulty saying no.
Step 6: Test the consequences. Can you identify a meaningful individual consequence and a broader social consequence? More importantly, can you find evidence supporting those connections? If not, the observation may be interesting but insufficient for a ten-minute speech. Remember that a relatable example demonstrates what a behavior looks like, but credible research helps establish whether it contributes to a meaningful problem.
Step 7: Challenge your explanation. Ask what other factors might explain the behavior, whether your interpretation is incomplete, and whether someone with a different life experience would understand the situation differently. This is where documentaries, particularly biographical documentaries, become valuable. Most competitive speech students are teenagers, and while there's nothing wrong with that, at 13, 15, or 17, you haven't yet encountered every kind of hardship, relationship, or difficult decision adulthood can bring. Learning about people with different experiences can challenge assumptions you didn't realize you were making. The goal isn't simply to collect dramatic stories. It's to understand the complexity behind human decisions.
Step 8: Turn your discovery into a working argument.
Complete the following statement: "We tend to ________ because we've come to believe ________, but that belief can lead to ________." For example, "We tend to avoid difficult conversations because we've come to believe that disagreement threatens relationships, but that belief can prevent us from addressing the very problems that damage them." This isn't your final thesis. It's a hypothesis that you can investigate, challenge, and refine. If the research supports it, you may have found the foundation of your next Original Oratory.
Final Thought: Make the Familiar Unfamiliar
The best Original Oratories often begin with something so ordinary that the audience has never thought to question it. A deleted text message, an unnecessary apology, an uncomfortable silence, or a person who desperately needs help but insists they're fine. On their own, these moments might seem insignificant, but when you investigate the beliefs, fears, and expectations beneath them, they can reveal something much larger about how we understand ourselves and one another.
That's what makes the process of developing an OO so fascinating. You're not simply searching for something wrong with society. You're learning to recognize the assumptions that shape our everyday lives, question whether those assumptions deserve our trust, and investigate what happens when they don't.
Sometimes, the most revealing thing about human behavior isn't what we do. It's how rarely we stop to ask why.
3P Original Oratory Writing Academy | Lesson 3
Coming Next: Developing a Thesis That Gives Your Speech Direction
You've discovered a behavior, investigated the belief behind it, and identified a meaningful problem. Now it's time to turn that research into a clear central argument that can guide every section of your speech.
Ready to Put It All Together?
Developing a compelling Original Oratory takes more than choosing an interesting topic. It requires finding an argument worth making, researching the forces behind it, and building a speech that changes how an audience sees the world.
If you’re struggling to connect those pieces, sometimes a fresh perspective makes all the difference.
At 3P Speech, we offer personalized coaching for students competing in Original Oratory and other speech and debate events. You can schedule a free 30-minute consultation to discuss your speech, your goals, and where your argument might need more work.



Comments